Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Sufism in Islam

If you cleave the heart of one drop of water, A hundred pure oceans emerges from it.
Fantastic. Only the Sufis can come up with sayings of such deep insight.
Bro Venugopal, we need to seek God Bro, we have got no choice, if we want to live and die in a peaceful state....And one says " They ask thee about the Soul, Soul is the command (amr) of the Lord thy God".Take it easy bro
Are you afraid of God?
I have read in a book that if you are praying think the God is looking at you and if not looking at you He is listening to you.I did that and with fear and respect I couldn't continue cause my legs were trembling, Imagine you are facing your Creator, I just trembled like a leaf man.
But shouldn't God be evoking love rather than fear?

Monday, June 29, 2009

Mohammad, the Guru

In the Hindu parlance, we can say that Mohammad was a Guru. He meditated in the caves, discovered God within himself and expressed that discovery in the imagery of his times. However, he never taught meditation as the path to self-discovery and his imagery got trapped in the Jewish prophetic tradition and hence God became an external phenomenon in Islam also. Only the Sufis sought to discover God within.

Living in our own light

Advaita only says not two. It doesn't exactly say one. Because there is no one at that stage to do any counting. Logically, only one is possible after a negation of two. But the one of Advaita means undifferentiated. Differentiation starts at two. But one also has a shade of differentiation, because it is countable. What is countable (singly or in groups) is an object. Advaita is about the subject. When we reach the state of the subject (as opposed to being among the objects), we have become the totality or Brahman and are no longer fragmented. Which again does not mean annihilation of objects per se, but only to us, who have become Brahman. Henceforth, instead of living on borrowed light, we live in our own light.
=======================
Is it truer to describe Truth as "is-ness" rather than "one-ness"?

Forms and formless are one

What we call God is nothing other than life. The whole of existence is nothing other than life or God in various forms. There is no difference between formless God and God in various forms. The idea of God having created forms is not true in the sense that God is separate from his creation. The formless becomes the forms, changes forms, and becomes formless again.
=======================
Logically understanding that there is no separation between us and all of existence would cause a radical shift in our living and our living, as life is, would become divine. Then praying, devotion, meditating, cultivating the heart, loving etc. would be the very qualities of our being.
=======================

Logical understanding and any mind-based reasoning lead to nothing, especially not to any radical shift. There can be no conviction about any product of the thinking process including unity because thinking process can yield only hypothesises and there is always the other voice in the mind who knows that the opposite of a hypothesis may also be true. You know it very well from your experience.
Stubborn insistence on using the mind or tricky claim that mind is neither good nor bad are covers for addiction to the mind of beginners who are still trapped in the mind. Once they experience for the first time no-mind (manage to overcome their fear of meditation), they taste from a different quality of realization and manage to abandon the reliance on logic. As long as they do not overcome that fear of meditation and no-mind, they are just playing with a useless primitive toy and cannot understand that even if you tell them so hundred times.
Self realization is not the same as any other realization, it is just a confusion of language as we use the same word "realization" in both of them. Self realization has nothing to do with mind and understanding.
This is extremely important! It makes all the basic difference

A brilliant exposition. I congratulate you. But when you say, "Logical understanding and any mind-based reasoning lead to nothing, especially not to any radical shift", the very fact that in communicating we need the logic of language proves that logic leads us and could be used to lead us beyond logic. Otherwise how do we go beyond logic into the realms of intuition?

==========================

Advaita

According to my understanding of Advaita, Advaita is the state of oneness of existence and there is no scope in its philosophy for anything like non-existence. I request the members of this forum to share their thoughts on this subject and tell me if I am right or wrong.
=====================
Can we say if a certain thing is true, its opposite is also true?
=====================
It is possible a person at one time owned a car and later did not. What is ruled out is a person simultaneously owning a car and not owning a car. Simultaneously, at the same time and at the same place, it cannot be both day and night.
Is there a truth that is valid at all places and times - its opposite never existing? Is the proposition that there is only existence such a truth, with its opposite not ever existing? (Existence per se, that is – not the existence or not of a particular thing.)
=====================
Is existence life? Is there anything in existence that is not life or alive? Is death only a change of form and therefore a myth?
=====================
If dying means ceasing existence, can existence ever cease?
=====================

Our perfect condition

Dear Rehan, The title of this thread, "The Concept of God in Hinduism and Islam" itself contains a flaw in the sense that Hinduism has more than one concept of God. Polytheism is just one of the concepts that Hindus hold. They also hold the concepts of monotheism, monism etc. Moreover, you started this thread by quoting Dr. Zakir Naik. I took up the thread to point out that Dr. Naik's contention that the Vedas call for believe in One God is misplaced, because the Vedas' acme teaching is Advaita or the oneness of existence.As a Hindu, I have multiple choices as to what to believe or even to not believe anything at all. As far as belief is concerned, no Hindu believes that only one path is correct and all others are wrong. Many Hindus eventually take up one of the great many meditative processes indicated in Hinduism and seek to discover God in the depths of their own consciousness. As far as my personal beliefs are concerned, I believe that we and our circumstances are perfect, have always been perfect and will ever be perfect. This is because we are God. And by God I mean nothing other than Life. Yes, our life is what we are and not the form that our life has taken up. Life takes up forms in a game of hide-and-seek it plays, where it loses itself and tries to re-discover itself. I hope all readers of my comments will note that I am not trying to say that Islam is wrong and Advaita alone is right. I am only trying to point out that there are many paths available to man to believe/realize God and it is his individual choice which path he chooses. All paths eventually would lead to the truth as all rivers eventually lead to the ocean.
===============
Positive thinking is fine. But dividing thoughts into positive and negative would involve suppressing negative thoughts out of the picture and such thoughts, as you said, might lie in our sub-consciousness to lurk when we are off-guard. The japa-technique is based on the sound-silence technique, where though you say only, for example, Rama-Rama-Rama, there is from the beginning an imperceptible pause in the uttering of the Ramas. So it is actually sound-silence-sound-silence. As we go on, they say, the silence takes over and the silent still mind experiences a peace that surpasseth understanding. As Jesus said, "Be still and know that I am God."
================
Very well put. We live in the present and we celebrate life spontaneously.
================
You are right. Labelling would do us in. But if we remember we are not sinners but divine creatures, we are quite there.
================
Wow! I see you are very advanced in your understanding. In short, as you would agree, it would be just watching without any judgement whatsoever. Then what remains is a life of awe! And a life of joy, without our differentiating what we are going through, right?
================
I can see the forcefulness of the point you are making. That life is perfect is plain if we see that one thing leads to another (cause-effect continuum) and if we find a certain situation imperfect, it is only because we have disassociated it from its cause and passed our uni-dimensional judgement upon it. Therefore when we say something is wrong, we are being subjective. Being subjective is undoubtedly a perfect situation, but often our subjectiveness is the cause of our suffering. Suffering of course is not a perfect situation because it is brought about by our isolated judgement upon a situation. Why restrict ourselves to isolated judgements and miss out on the perfection we have inherited?

Monday, June 22, 2009

French President Sarkozy: Burqas "will not be welcome on the territory of the French Republic."

France, which prides itself as the harbinger of modern democracy in Europe and a forerunner to a secular intellectual society has been unable to develop an inclusive culture. Maybe the hangover of some Christian (read Churchian) legacy of intolerance? Burqua might seem an antediluvian Islamic symbol of terrorism, but can’t the French accept it as a modern fashion statement? At least in gay Paris, the fashion capital of the world? Let it learn from India the secret of its inclusive culture. The only way to go after Islamic terrorism is to challenge the Islamic claim that the Quranic way of thinking is the only valid way.

===============

If France is going to have a Muslim population, never mind if only miniscule (still the largest Muslim population in Europe) it might as well allow it its freedom of identity (without breaking French civil laws, of course. And ensuring idiotic French laws like 'no burqas’ are not made). And do you think all truth emits only from the Quran? I am sure you don't. So why not put the record straight and douse the fanatic zeal of the terrorists who imagine fighting to establish Islam on earth is a small mercy to mankind which would get light from nowhere else! Fears of Muslims becoming wild thus challenged and burning embassies is not becoming of any nation, least of all the great French civilization, for whom truth is the ultimate.

===============

Let Muslims practise their religion and maintain their religious identity. The fight is against terrorism and its basic cause. In the case of Islamic terrorism, it is the claim of Islam that its teachings alone constitute the truth. If this claim is invalidated by the sheer force of reasoning by non-Muslims or if Muslims maintain that Islam does not teach that it alone has the truth and teachings to the contrary are un-Islamic, Islamic terrorism will die a natural death.